Welcome to Classico Pizzeria, a hidden gem nestled in West Islip, NY, at 5 Udall Rd. This delightful pizza restaurant offers a unique blend of traditional Italian flavors and modern culinary innovation. With a cozy atmosphere and friendly staff, Classico Pizzeria has quickly become a local favorite, drawing patrons in with the rich aroma of freshly baked pizza and savory sides.
What sets Classico apart is its attention to detail in crafting an extensive menu. From the classic Chicken Vegetable soup at $8.75 to the vibrant Greek Salad priced at $8.95, there’s something for everyone. Not to mention, the renowned tri-color grandma pie received rave reviews from customers like Richie Stack, who described it as potentially his favorite slice anywhere. This level of quality and creativity is not only exciting for the taste buds but it also speaks volumes about the skilled chefs behind the counter.
The pizza selection does not stop at the traditional offerings. Customers have sung praises for the unique flavors such as the bacon pizza, favored by Anthony7124’s grandson, which highlights the restaurant's ability to cater to diverse palates, especially for families. The standout Classico Hero—a pizza variant featuring chicken Francese, mozzarella, and hot cherry peppers—is an interesting twist that showcases their creative culinary approach.
Beyond pizzas, the menu also offers a variety of salads, sides, and delectable soups, making it a well-rounded dining destination. The sautéed broccoli rabe and garlic bread with mozzarella are perfect complements to any meal, while the inviting atmosphere ensures you feel right at home. Each element, from the friendly service to the meticulously crafted dishes, contributes to a holistic dining experience.
As noted by Danielle DiNapoli, the cleanliness and inviting nature of Classico Pizzeria only add to its charm. With pie prices ranging from $4 to $5.25, this pizzeria provides gourmet flavors without breaking the bank. The presence of additional shops nearby creates a convenient stop for a cozy meal after errands, making it a practical choice for the community.
As a food reviewer, I am highly impressed by the passion reflected in every dish served at Classico Pizzeria. The dedication to quality and customer satisfaction is evident, making it a must-visit spot in West Islip. Whether you're a local or just passing through, be sure to swing by this extraordinary pizzeria for an unforgettable experience.
So why wait? Grab your friends, savor the flavors, and indulge in the cheesy, saucy goodness that Classico Pizzeria has to offer. Your taste buds will thank you!
Your opinion matters! Help other visitors discover this spot. Your email will stay private. Fields with * are required.
Av. Eugenio Garza Sada 127, Pocitos, 20328 Pocitos, Ags., Mexico
Tv. 54 #103B-25, Bogota, Colombia
2398 OR-35, Hood River, OR 97031, United States
9600 Club House Dr A, Charlevoix, MI 49720, United States
12118 NM-14, Cedar Crest, NM 87008, United States
Richie Stack
09/10/2025
Excellent Pizza and really nice staff. The Tri-color grandma pie might be my new favorite slice of pizza anywhere. Will definitely be returning!
Anthony7124
07/10/2025
My grandsons favorite place. Lives the bacon pizza the best ? ( This week Lol). However I too truly like the place. Great good great people. Worth a try for sure. Enjoy.
Danielle DiNapoli
14/09/2025
Clean, inviting pizzeria with delicious slices. The tri-color grandma and chicken Francese with hot cherry peppers are showstoppers. The crust is soft but crispy. The pizza flavors are delicious. Staff are attentive and friendly also. Slice prices range ~$4-$5.25. it shares a lot with a laundromat, supermarket, and some other shops but there are some parking spaces available in front Do yourself a favor and order the Classico Hero: chicken Francese, mozzarella and hot cherry peppers. This in pizza form is great, and somehow the hero is even better
David S
11/09/2025
Local, local local... One less star for credit card fees added to your bill, why? Nice local place, friendly service, lots of choices makes this a great little pizza/restaurant to go to! Oh yeah, the tricolor pesto is great, as is the cherry pepper chicken francese slice are both great choices not to be found anywhere else!
David Villano Jr.
27/08/2025
So my girlfriend and I recently moved in the area. Now though there’s a pizzeria closer to my apartment but this pizzeria is worth the drive. This pizzeria has much more variety and the owners and pizza makers are very friendly and they work very hard. Even though they didn’t have any Caesar salad slices and they still made us Caesar slices and it came out very well. The pasta slices are out of this world. Very well done. Top tier customer service and pizza slices. This place is definitely underrated! Thank you for such a good Sunday dinner!! Will definitely return soon!
Mark McKeon
27/08/2025
I've only order twice from here so far but, I will say the food that I ordered was great! I can't say much for atmosphere or service because it was quick takeout transactions, not much to base an opinion from. I will say the place appeared to be clean and inviting. On Valentine's Day I ordered a heart shaped cheese pie for the kids and they loved it. Pizza had great flavor, quality cheese as well. Garlic knots were perfect with a ton of flavor. We ordered a couple of vodka slices and I will say certainly the best vodka slice I've had yet ! They have a bunch of other pies that look not only interesting but delicious. Check out the website and social media pages to see the line up, they even have personal pies! This review was not paid for, I don't know them, I'm not affiliated in any way. Just go try the pizza it speaks for itself!